The Dangerous Truth The Talented Mr. Ripley Reveals About Envy

The Talented Mr. Ripley is usually described as a thriller about a con man. It is something more unsettling: a portrait of a person with no stable self, who looks at someone else’s life and concludes that the only way to have it is to become it.

About the film: The Talented Mr. Ripley (dir. Anthony Minghella, 1999), adapted from Patricia Highsmith’s 1955 novel, follows Tom Ripley, a young man in New York who is sent to Italy by a wealthy shipbuilder to bring his son, Dickie Greenleaf, back home. Tom insinuates himself into Dickie’s glamorous life — and into his identity. This article discusses the full plot, including the ending.

The first lie Tom Ripley tells is small. A borrowed Princeton jacket at a party in New York, and a man who assumes Tom went to university with his son. Tom does not correct him. It is not exactly a plan. It is something closer to a reflex: someone offers him an identity, and he steps into it as easily as into a coat.

Everything that follows in the film grows out of that moment. Tom arrives in Italy, studies Dickie’s tastes, learns jazz because Dickie loves jazz, imitates his voice, his signature, his gestures. He is charming, attentive, useful. And underneath all of it is a question the film never states out loud but asks in every scene: what happens to a person who has no self of their own when they meet someone who seems to have too much?

The dangerous truth The Talented Mr. Ripley reveals about envy is that envy is not always the wish to have what another person has. Sometimes it is the wish to erase the difference between you — to stop being yourself altogether.

Envy and Admiration Are Not Opposites

Melanie Klein (1957) distinguished envy from jealousy with a precision that still holds. Jealousy involves three people: I fear losing someone I love to a rival. Envy involves two: I cannot bear that you possess something good that I do not. And Klein’s most unsettling observation was that envy contains an impulse to spoil the good thing — because if I cannot have it, its existence in you is a constant reminder of my lack.

Tom’s feelings for Dickie are a mixture that Klein would have recognised immediately. He admires Dickie. He is drawn to him, perhaps in love with him. And he cannot tolerate that Dickie has everything — the money, the ease, the beautiful girlfriend, the effortless sense of belonging — while Tom has nothing but his talent for imitation. Admiration and envy are not opposites in Tom. They are the same feeling seen from two sides.

Admiration says: I want to be near what you have. Envy says: I cannot bear that it is yours and not mine. Tom lives in the space where those two sentences become one.

The False Self — A Life Built From Imitation

Donald Winnicott (1960) described the false self: a way of being that develops when a child learns that their spontaneous feelings are not welcome, and builds instead a compliant surface organised around what others want. The false self is not a lie in the ordinary sense. It is a survival structure — and it leaves behind a person who often feels empty, unreal, unsure of who they are when no one is watching.

Tom Ripley is the false self taken to its extreme. He has extraordinary skill in reading others and becoming what they expect. What he lacks is anything underneath. When he admits to a talent for forging signatures, telling lies and impersonating practically anybody, he is describing his gift. He is also describing his tragedy: a man whose only real ability is to be someone else.

Helene Deutsch (1942) described a related phenomenon she called the “as-if” personality: people who seem perfectly normal and adapted, but whose emotional life is borrowed — they feel what those around them feel, adopt the opinions of whoever is near, and change identity when the company changes. It is one of the most accurate clinical portraits ever written of a character like Tom.

Why Rejection Becomes Unbearable

The turning point of the film comes when Dickie grows tired of Tom. The admiration that flattered him at first starts to feel like a weight. He tells Tom, in effect, that their time together is over. For most people this would be painful. For Tom it is annihilating.

To understand why, it helps to remember what Dickie represents. For Tom, Dickie is not just a friend he is losing. He is the self Tom had been borrowing. Losing Dickie means falling back into the emptiness he had briefly escaped. The violence on the boat at San Remo is not planned in the way a crime novel would usually frame it. It erupts out of that unbearable return — envy, love, humiliation and terror of nothingness collapsing into one act.

And then the most chilling part of the film begins. Tom does not run. He becomes Dickie. He signs his name, wears his clothes, lives in his apartments. For a while, the envy is resolved in the most literal way possible: there is no longer any difference between them, because only one of them is left.

What the Film Teaches About Envy in Real Life

Few people who envy someone become Tom Ripley. But the dynamic the film dramatises appears in much smaller forms all the time. The friend who copies your style, your job, your way of speaking — and then becomes cold when you set yourself apart. The colleague whose admiration turns into quiet sabotage. The partner who first idealises you and then cannot forgive you for having what they lack.

The common thread is a fragile self that experiences someone else’s fullness as an injury. We explored the imitation side of this — why people copy others without knowing — in why you copy others without knowing, and the shifting identity that adapts to every room in why you sound different with everyone. Ripley is what those ordinary patterns look like when nothing holds them back.

The Ending — Locked in the Basement of Himself

The film ends on a ship bound for Greece. Peter, the one person who genuinely loves Tom as Tom, is with him. Tom tells him about a basement in his mind where he keeps everything locked away, and about wanting someone to share the key. Moments later, to keep his borrowed life intact, he kills Peter. In the final shot, Tom sits alone in his cabin, and the swinging door of the wardrobe mirror reflects him back and forth into darkness.

Peter was the closest Tom ever came to being known. And the dangerous truth of the ending is that Tom destroys the one relationship that could have made him real, in order to preserve the identity that keeps him empty.

Envy, in its most extreme form, does not make a person richer. It makes them disappear. Tom gets everything Dickie had, and is left with less of himself than he had at the beginning.

For another film about identity built entirely on surface, see the dangerous truth American Psycho reveals about identity.

Keep Reading

References

  1. Deutsch, H. (1942). Some forms of emotional disturbance and their relationship to schizophrenia. The Psychoanalytic Quarterly, 11(3), 301–321.
  2. Klein, M. (1957). Envy and gratitude: A study of unconscious sources. Tavistock.
  3. Minghella, A. (Director). (1999). The talented Mr. Ripley [Film]. Paramount Pictures; Miramax Films.
  4. Winnicott, D. W. (1965). Ego distortion in terms of true and false self. In The maturational processes and the facilitating environment (pp. 140–152). Hogarth Press. (Original work published 1960)

If You Want to Go Further

The best companion to the film is the novel it came from. Patricia Highsmith’s The Talented Mr. Ripley gives Tom an inner voice the film can only suggest — and reading his rationalisations from the inside is one of the most disturbing and illuminating experiences in crime fiction.

The Talented Mr. Ripley — Patricia Highsmith

(affiliate link)


Discover more from Hidden Patterns

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top