Why You Feel Crazy Around One Person — The Hidden Truth

With everyone else you are calm, reasonable, recognisably yourself. With one person you become someone you do not recognise — furious, confused, ashamed, convinced you are losing your mind. Psychoanalysis has a name for what may be happening, and it changes the question you should be asking.

You have always been the steady one. Friends describe you as patient. Colleagues come to you when things go wrong. And yet with this one person — a partner, a parent, a sibling, a boss — something happens that you cannot explain. You raise your voice. You say cruel things you would never say to anyone else. You leave conversations shaking, replaying every word, unsure whether what you remember really happened.

And at the worst moments the other person looks at you with perfect calm and says: “You see? You’re the one who’s out of control.”

Most people in this situation draw the obvious conclusion: there must be something wrong with me. Sometimes that is true. But there is another possibility that almost nobody considers — that some of what you are feeling is not originally yours.

Projective Identification — When a Feeling Moves House

In 1946, Melanie Klein described a psychological mechanism she called projective identification. It begins with something familiar: a person cannot tolerate a feeling of their own — rage, shame, helplessness, a sense of being mad — and gets rid of it by attributing it to someone else. That part is ordinary projection: “I’m not angry, you are.”

Projective identification goes one step further. Through the pressure of the relationship — provocations, denials, silences, small humiliations, a particular tone of voice — the other person ends up actually feeling what was projected into them. You are not merely accused of being furious. You become furious. And the person who could not bear the feeling can now point at it, with relief, because it is no longer inside them. It is inside you.

Thomas Ogden (1979) described the process in three moments: a fantasy of getting rid of an unwanted part of the self; interpersonal pressure that pushes the other person to experience it; and the other person living it as their own. What makes it so disorienting is the third moment. The feeling is genuinely yours now. It is just not where it started.

Sometimes the clearest evidence of what another person cannot feel is everything you end up feeling in their presence.

Not Always a Weapon

Wilfred Bion (1962) added something important: projective identification is not only a defence. It is also one of the earliest forms of communication. A baby who cannot yet think about distress makes its mother feel it — and a good-enough mother receives that feeling, thinks about it, and gives it back in a form the baby can bear. Bion called this containment.

In healthy relationships, adults do this for each other all the time. Your partner comes home with a tension they cannot name, you feel it, and the two of you think about it together until it becomes something that can be spoken. The feeling travels, is understood, and loses its power.

In damaging relationships the feeling travels and nobody thinks about it. It simply circulates, and you carry it. The person who sent it never takes it back. Over months and years you become the official holder of the relationship’s rage, confusion or shame — and you begin to believe that this is who you are.

How It Connects to Gaslighting

The word gaslighting has become common, sometimes too common. The sociologist Paige Sweet (2019) described it as a form of abuse that works by making the victim seem — and feel — irrational, and noted how it draws on existing power imbalances to make one person’s version of reality the official one.

Projective identification helps explain why gaslighting works so well. It is not only that the other person denies what happened. It is that, by the time they deny it, you are already flooded with confusion and anger that make you look exactly like the unreliable one they describe. The denial lands on fertile ground that the relationship itself prepared.

A Practical Question to Ask Yourself

Psychoanalysts learn to use what they feel in the presence of a patient as information about the patient. It is called countertransference, and it is one of the most useful ideas psychoanalysis has to offer ordinary life: what you feel in a relationship is data about the relationship, not only about you.

If you become aggressive, insecure or confused with only one person, the question is not just “what is wrong with me?” but also “what is being placed in me here?” This does not erase your responsibility for what you do. Shouting is still shouting. But it stops you from concluding that you are a bad or unstable person simply because of what one relationship makes you feel.

One simple exercise: for two weeks, before and after every important conversation with that person, rate from 0 to 10 how much rage, shame, confusion and guilt you feel. If the numbers rise consistently after talking to them — and not after talking to anyone else — you are not looking at a trait of yours. You are looking at a pattern of the relationship.

The Way Back to Yourself

The hidden truth about feeling crazy around one person is that the craziness may be an accurate response to something real. Not a sign that you are broken, but a sign that you have been asked, without consent, to hold what someone else could not.

Getting out of that position does not require convincing the other person of anything. It requires noticing, naming and gradually refusing the role — and, often, finding people who give you back a more accurate picture of who you are when you are not inside that relationship.

For the cycle that so often surrounds this dynamic, see the alarming cycle narcissists use to destroy relationships. And for why the most empathic people are the ones most often chosen to carry these feelings, the hidden reason you always attract narcissists.

Keep Reading

References

  1. Bion, W. R. (1962). Learning from experience. Heinemann.
  2. Klein, M. (1946). Notes on some schizoid mechanisms. International Journal of Psycho-Analysis, 27, 99–110.
  3. Ogden, T. H. (1979). On projective identification. International Journal of Psycho-Analysis, 60, 357–373.
  4. Sweet, P. L. (2019). The sociology of gaslighting. American Sociological Review, 84(5), 851–875. https://doi.org/10.1177/0003122419874843

If You Want to Go Further

The most practical book on the experience of having your reality systematically questioned is Robin Stern’s The Gaslight Effect. Stern, a psychoanalyst and co-founder of the Yale Center for Emotional Intelligence, describes the stages through which a person comes to doubt their own perception — and offers concrete steps for recovering it.

The Gaslight Effect — Robin Stern

(affiliate link)


Discover more from Hidden Patterns

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top